Carmen Lopez
Revised topic paragraph
Research question: Are dioramas and miniature models still a good medium
for a museum to use or are they a thing from the past?
In this revision of my project, I have focused more on the use of
dioramas and miniature models in the exhibition space, rather than specifically
looking at how to exhibit paper theatres. I would still develop my project
hinging on the paper theatres at Geva, but I would be looking at a bigger range
of replica models that museums use in exhibitions spaces. I also want to discuss
the idea of some dioramas being extremely inaccurate and this possibly making
them be a dying museum trend. My project would be an investigation of dioramas
made to represent actual size things, miniature dioramas and taxidermy, to see
if they have an educational use. “The Cinema as Taxidermy: Carl Akeley and the
Preservative Obsession” is an article that is speaking about the history of
dioramas, specifically looking at the work of Carl Akeley. “Postmortem
Exhibitions: Taxidermy Animals and Platinated Corpses in the Theaters of the
Dead” is addressing the problem some visitors have with taxidermy and
displaying dead remains. “A Window on the
World—Wildlife Dioramas” is a book discussing the dioramas in the American
Museum of Natural History. “Learning With: ‘What’s Wrong with This Diorama? is
an article talking about the case study of the American Museum of Natural
History’s diorama depicting the Lenape indigenous tribe. And how the museum is
now using its inaccurate historical details as a tool, to teach people the true
history.
Alvey, Mark. “The Cinema as Taxidermy: Carl Akeley and the Preservative
Obsession.” Framework: The Journal of Cinema and Media 48, no. 1 (February 8,
2007): 23–45. https://doi.org/10.1353/frm.2007.0000.
Desmond, Jane. “Postmortem Exhibitions: Taxidermied Animals and
Plastinated Corpses in the Theaters of the Dead.” Configurations 16, no. 3
(2008): 347–78. https://doi.org/10.1353/con.0.0062.
Morris, Pat. “A Window on the
World—Wildlife Dioramas.” In Natural
History Dioramas: History, Construction and Educational Role, edited by Sue
Dale Tunnicliffe and Annette Scheersoi, 33–37. Dordrecht: Springer Netherlands,
2015. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-94-017-9496-1_4.
Engle, Jeremy. “Learning With: ‘What’s
Wrong With This Diorama? You Can Read All About It’: Article of the Day.” New
York Times (Online); New York, March 22, 2019. http://search.proquest.com/docview/2195092040/abstract/9B42DB19727846E5PQ/1.
Carmen, this is an interesting question that leads me to ask why dioramas were so prevalent? Why do you think that is? Is it about the ability to harness or tame nature? Or something else? You might look through some older newspapers to get a sense of why the dioramas took hold in the US (other places, too, but US might be easier to research) in the 19th century in order to understand how museums moved beyond them. Looking forward to reading more!
ReplyDelete